• Home
  • News
    • Politics / Govt
    • Legislature
    • Crime / Courts
    • Health / Medicine
    • Archives
  • Sports
    • Badgers
    • Packers
      • Titletown Report
    • Brewers
  • Contact Us
    • Reporters
  • Affiliates
    • Affiliate Support

Wisconsin Radio Network

Wisconsin News and Sports

You are here: Home / Crime / Courts / State Supreme Court says hearsay allowed at preliminary hearings

State Supreme Court says hearsay allowed at preliminary hearings

July 9, 2014 By Andrew Beckett

The Wisconsin Supreme Court (Photo: Andrew Beckett)

The Wisconsin Supreme Court (Photo: Andrew Beckett)

The Wisconsin Supreme Court is upholding a state law that allow hearsay evidence to be presented at preliminary hearings in felony cases. Justices ruled 6-1 on Wednesday that the 2012 state law is constitutional, after three people challenged it in court.

The legislature approved the measure partially to keep crime victims from being forced to testify in court during the early stages of a criminal case. Those hearings are when a judge typically determines if there’s enough evidence for someone to be bound over for trial, and victim’s advocates worried that forcing them to appear in court that early in the process could cause further harm. Since the change, most of the testimony at preliminary hearings now comes from police officers, who generally present the evidence they have obtained that resulted in the initial arrest.

Legal challenges were filed by Kathleen and Martin O’Brien, a Walworth County couple accused of child abuse, and Charles Butts of Kenosha, who was charged with sexual assault of a child and child enticement. They argued that the law violates their constitutional rights to confront their accusers.

The court’s majority rejected that argument though, ruling that defendants have no constitutional right to question their accusers during preliminary hearings. Writing for the majority, Justice Ann Walsh Bradley noted that the hearings are only used to determine if there’s probable cause and sufficient evidence to show a felony was committed. Bradley notes that those charged with a crime still have the ability to confront their accuser during the actual trial.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Filed Under: Crime / Courts, News



Featured Stories

Packers season comes to an end in NFC Championship

Legendary Hank Aaron passes away

Ted Thompson passed away at age 68 (AUDIO)

Big Ten suspends Wisconsin’s Ahcan

Bucks lose tight battle with Nets

TwitterFacebook

Listen Now | More from Titletown »

Sports Headlines

Packers season comes to an end in NFC Championship

Legendary Hank Aaron passes away

Bucks drop second straight, fall at home to Lakers

Hockey Badgers grab series opener at Penn State

Wisconsin’s Mark Johnson named WCHA 1970’s Player of the Decade

More Sports

Tweets by @WRN

Get our news delivered to your inbox:

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Copyright © 2021 · Learfield News & Ag, LLC